Mind the Coverage Gap (A Look at Healthcare Sharing Ministries)

Painting of Christ healing the sick
Flickr/Creative Commons—Ted

By Gregory M. Lipper

The Wall Street Journal published a story earlier this week about an increase in the number of Americans enrolling in healthcare sharing ministries: faith-based alternatives to standard health insurance. According to the Journal, the number of participants in these ministries has grown from under 200,000, before the Affordable Care Act was enacted, to approximately 500,000 today. Under 26 U.S.C. § 5000A(d)(2)(B), participants in these ministries are exempt from the Act’s individual mandate, which requires most Americans to either obtain qualifying health insurance coverage or pay a tax.

As the Journal article makes clear, however, participants in healthcare ministries lack many of the protections otherwise provided to patients by the Affordable Care Act. For example,

  • Ministries often don’t cover preexisting conditions;
  • Ministries often don’t cover preventive care; and
  • Ministries often don’t cover contraception, maternity care, or mental-health care.

If and when coverage disputes arise, moreover, “[m]inistries generally don’t allow members to sue and require disagreements to be settled by arbitration and mediation.”

Read More